ACE Music v1 ranks first on Artificial Analysis’s vocal music leaderboard, scoring 1160 against Suno v6’s 1144. That’s a lead on one benchmark, not a verdict on every song. The benchmark lets each model write its own lyrics and sing them. If you already have lyrics, run a separate test with the same words on both models before deciding which one to use.
What does ACE Music v1’s 16-point lead mean?
Artificial Analysis (@ArtificialAnlys) announced ACE’s debut at No. 1 on November 11, 2026. The AA-Music-Vocal v1.1 leaderboard still showed these figures when checked on November 15:
| Model | Displayed rank | Elo-like score | 95% interval | Rank range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ACE Music v1 | 1 | 1160 ± 21 | 1139–1181 | 1–2 |
| Suno v6 | 2 | 1144 ± 18 | 1126–1162 | 1–3 |
The displayed ranks order the score estimates. The intervals overlap, and the leaderboard’s rank ranges also overlap. Overlap alone is not a formal test of the gap between two models; the table supports saying ACE led this snapshot, not claiming a decisive or universal advantage. The 16 points are rating points, not a 16-percentage-point win margin.
What the vocal benchmark actually tests
In the Artificial Analysis methodology, verified private evaluators compare two tracks generated from the same prompt without seeing the model names. They must hear at least ten seconds of each track before voting. Tracks are gain-adjusted toward a common loudness target. Public Arena votes do not determine the official rating.
Because the benchmark supplies no lyrics, the vote reflects the combined result of songwriting, arrangement, vocal delivery, and sound. It doesn’t isolate diction, adherence to your lyrics, or how much editing a track needs. The listening minimum also doesn’t require everyone to hear the ending.
Instrumentals are scored separately. On the instrumental leaderboard, Suno v6 led among listed models at the November 15 check; ACE Music v1 was not listed. That’s not an instrumental head-to-head result.
Which model should you try for your workflow?
| If you want to… | Start here |
|---|---|
| Turn a short idea into a new vocal song | Try both. ACE’s benchmark lead is a reason to include it, especially if you want the model to write the lyrics. |
| Sing your own lyrics with specific delivery cues | Test ACE Music v1, which accepts performance directions in the lyrics. Compare against Suno using the same words and intended delivery. |
| Revise an existing Suno song | Start with Suno v6’s documented editing workflow. If phrasing is the problem, try a self-recorded guide vocal. |
| Take a candidate into a DAW | ACE offers MIDI conversion and stem separation. Suno offers stem extraction and Studio exports. Check what your plan exports; extracted stems aren’t original multitracks. |
Run a useful ACE vs Suno listening test
- Hold the brief fixed. Use the same genre, language, section structure and vocal direction. Run one round from a description only, and a second with your own fixed lyric sheet. Don’t mix the results.
- Compare multiple full takes. Start with at least three candidates per model in each round; don’t discard failed takes. Use similar playback levels and hide the model labels where possible. Check lyric accuracy, chorus lift, and whether the final chorus still sounds coherent.
- Count usable takes and editing time. If one tool delivers your preferred singer but keeps dropping a line, record that trade-off. The best model for the project is the one that gets you to a usable track within your time and budget.
You can use Meloty Agent to tighten the lyric sheet and turn production notes into a reusable prompt. Take the same brief into each model’s own interface; this comparison does not imply either model is hosted on Meloty.
Can you use ACE Music v1 outputs commercially?
ACE Music’s terms make the plan at generation time the deciding factor for v1: free-plan outputs are non-commercial, and upgrading later does not license old free outputs. Paid-plan permissions already granted are not revoked by cancellation. The pricing page also lists no downloads for free v1 output; don’t assume the ACE-Step exception applies to v1.
For Suno, check both its paid-plan rights guidance and its rules for tracks made before subscribing. A platform’s commercial permission does not establish copyright protection or clear third-party material for you.
Is ACE Music v1 open source?
The ranked ACE Music v1 is the browser model. Its official page announces plans to open-source ACE Music v1 Flash, a separate variant; a plan is not a release of the ranked model’s weights. ACE-Step 1.5 is a different, already open-source family with its own permissions. ACE Music v1.1 Preview, which the provider describes as score- and melody-oriented, is also not the v1 entry shown in the table.
Sources checked November 15, 2026. This is an analysis of the published benchmark and product documentation, not a new Meloty listening test.

